Insurer raising its rates by 44%

 

Florida Times Union
 

By URVAKSH KARKARIA
urvaksh.karkariajacksonville.com, (904) 359-4367

12/19/2005

 

 
Hurricane season has barreled through Florida leaving its trademark trail of chaos. But for some residents, the storms continue to unleash a financial hammering.

Citizens Property Insurance Corp. is bumping up insurance rates by a statewide average of 44 percent for homeowners in high-risk areas, including up to a 40.5 percent hike for some of those policyholders living on the First Coast. That, however, pales in comparison to the 127.8 percent increase for some residents in Escambia County, where Hurricane Ivan hammered the Pensacola Bay area in 2004, followed by bouts with Dennis and Katrina this year.

--------------------------------------------------
40.5 percent rate increase Citizens Property Insurance Corp.'s board approved a 44 percent statewide average rate increase for homeowners in high-risk areas.
The rate hike will add about $1,028 to the average homeowner's insurance cost for a total average of $3,363.
Some policyholders living in high risk areas on the First Coast will see rate increases of up to 40.5 percent.
--------------------------------------------------
Hurricane-related losses have many Florida insurers scurrying for financial cover. More than 20 companies such as Cincinnati Indemnity Co., Cincinnati Insurance Co. and Florida Select Insurance Co. have sought rate increases this year. Several firms, including Nationwide Insurance Co. of Florida, have given notice they will cut back on coverage. Seattle-based Safeco has stopped issuing new homeowners' policies in Florida and said it will not renew existing policies starting in January.
"Citizens is supposed to be the [insurer] of last resort," said Jeff Grady, president of the Florida Association of Insurance Agents, which represents more than 1,300 independent agencies statewide. "Unfortunately, they are the [insurer] of only resort in Florida right now along the coastline."
Although Citizens' spike in premiums might startle some policyholders, one industry lobbyist shrugs off the move as inevitable.
The rate increase, which must be approved by the state Office of Insurance Regulation, will add about $1,028 to the average homeowner's insurance cost for a total average of $3,363.
Citizens insurance, which covers about 800,000 people statewide, including more than 10,800 in Northeast Florida, is available to those who can't find coverage in the private market. It is the second-largest insurer after State Farm.
The rate increase is necessary to maintain reserves to pay future claims, said Mark Goldwich, public adjuster with Jacksonville-based Gold Star Adjusters.
Citizens "certainly [is] not taking in ... what they are paying out in claims," Goldwich said.
The increase, approved by Citizen's board Thursday, is in addition to a 16.2 percent increase in high-risk coastal areas that was approved last February. Last month, the insurer increased residential property insurance rates by a statewide average of roughly 15 percent to keep pace with rate inflation among private insurers. That increase was based on an analysis of the top 20 residential property insurance rates in the state
Citizens tallied a $516 million deficit last year and is expecting a roughly $1 billion deficit this year. The increases don't factor in damage of up to $1 billion from Hurricane Wilma, which may force another round of price increases for Citizens, said Justin Glover, a company spokesman.
Citizens' deficit is "indicative that their rates are not adequate," Grady said. "I know that pains people who are paying pretty high prices already, to hear. But there is just a mountain of losses."
When asked to speculate on where the ceiling for such rate increases might be, Goldwich made a gloomy prediction: "I'm not sure that there is one. As long as we keep getting storms, [insurers] are going to have to keep raising rates."
Worse, there is little that consumers can do about it.
"There are very few companies willing to write," Grady said. "[Therefore] consumers are forced to do business with Citizens if they want to have their property insured."

The Associated Press contributed to this story.